Nov 17, 2026 · @David https://x.com/myrtlebeachnews
MYRTLE BEACH — When Long Bay Theatre raised the curtain on Mary Poppins at its new downtown home on Oct. 7, the paint had barely dried. The day before opening night, crews were still finishing construction and painting inside the building [WPDE, 2026]. The show ran through Oct. 25, and the nonprofit company is now preparing its second production on Main Street. The excitement surrounding the Long Bay Theatre Opened marks a significant moment for the local arts scene.
The timing matters to more than theater fans. Long Bay’s 200-seat house became the first theater to open in downtown Myrtle Beach’s arts district. That put it ahead of the publicly financed, roughly $23 million theater being built across the street.
One project was paid for by community donors. The other is being paid for by Myrtle Beach taxpayers. Both are betting that Horry County residents will come downtown after dark. Here is what opened, how Long Bay got here, and what it means for a Main Street the city has spent years trying to revive.
The Long Bay Theatre Opened to much anticipation, highlighting its role in revitalizing the area.
Until this fall, Long Bay Theatre opened at the Dream House Theatre inside the Myrtle Beach Mall. From there it ran a full season of plays and musicals from August through May [Sasee, 2025]. The new venue gives the company more room, a larger stage and 200 seats, about twice the audience its old home could hold.
The company’s ticketing site lists the address as 728 Main Street, in the city’s Arts & Innovation District. It calls the space Long Bay Theatre at The Hon. Brenda Bethune Theatre Center [Long Bay Theatre box office, 2026]. Bethune was mayor when the city broke ground on the downtown theater project in 2024. At that ceremony, she described the district as the reawakening of a downtown that needed to come alive for residents and visitors [Coastal Carolina University, 2024].
The money for Long Bay’s build-out came from community donations through a capital campaign with a $1 million goal. The theater is still collecting gifts for that campaign and for a Center Stage Fund that supports future productions. Neither local station that covered the opening reported what the building work actually cost, so the final price tag remains an open question.
The opening show, Disney and Cameron Mackintosh’s Mary Poppins, was billed as the family event of the season [Long Bay Theatre box office, 2026]. In September, the company let WMBF film rehearsals and talked about the new space it was building to expand arts programming.
The choice of a familiar family musical was a sensible one. A new address needs a show that brings grandparents, parents and kids through the door together, many of them for the first time downtown in years.
The move to Main Street is the latest act in a long, nomadic story. Founder and artistic director Greg London first staged shows when the Long Bay Theatre opened at the old Palace Theatre in 2007 [Sasee, 2025]. London, a South Carolina native who taught theater at Coastal Carolina University for seven years, has said the company began as a partnership with the Palace [Grand Strand Magazine, 2025].
The Palace closed after Hurricane Matthew, and Long Bay went quiet while London took work elsewhere [Sasee, 2025; Grand Strand Magazine, 2025]. He was working in Atlanta when COVID-19 shut theaters down, and he came home to plan a return. The comeback started with a socially distanced, outdoor Godspell in a parking lot at Broadway at the Beach. London calls that production the company’s rebirth [Sasee, 2025].
Since then, Long Bay Theatre opened between borrowed spaces. It has performed at the now-closed OZ Nightlife at Broadway at the Beach [Grand Strand Magazine, 2025] and the Long Bay Theatre Opened at the former First Presbyterian Church on North Kings Highway [BroadwayWorld, 2022], before settling at the mall.
That history explains why a permanent home matters so much. A company that moves every few years has to rebuild its audience every time. It also cannot easily plan seasons in advance or invest in sets and equipment it may not be able to store. A building on Main Street gives Long Bay something it has rarely had: an address people can find.
It also strengthens a pipeline that already reaches across the county. Long Bay works with roughly 70 Coastal Carolina University theater majors, and for many of them it is their first paid professional job [Sasee, 2025]. A bigger stage downtown means more of those jobs can stay local.
Long Bay’s new home sits across the street from the city’s own theater project, a joint effort with Coastal Carolina University. That 300-seat venue combines three historic Main Street buildings: the old Helen Mates Dress Shop, J&J Drugs and the Broadway Theater. Ground was broken in July 2024, with a grand opening targeted for summer 2026 [Coastal Carolina University, 2024].
That target has slipped. Construction was supposed to wrap up in August, but the steel structure had to be redesigned to the correct dimensions. The city now expects to finish in November.
The cost has also grown. In February 2024, the city put construction at about $12 million [City of Myrtle Beach, 2024]. The Sun News now reports a budget of roughly $23.3 million including land, inside an Arts and Innovation District budget of about $80 million. The city is covering construction partly with a bank loan. About $4.9 million in historic and abandoned-building tax credits is expected to help offset the bill [BroadwayWorld, 2024].
Once the building is finished, CCU will sublease it from the city. Each year the university gets at least 150 days for its own use, 100 days for outside groups booked through CCU, and the city keeps 30. Mayor Mark Kruea criticized the theater during his campaign as too expensive for too few seats. After a recent council discussion of possible savings, he told The Sun News that no large cuts appeared to be coming.
The two projects are not an equal comparison. Turning three historic buildings into a modern performance hall is a bigger and costlier job than fitting out a community stage, and Long Bay’s total spending has not been made public. Still, taxpayers are likely to notice the contrast. A small nonprofit raised money from neighbors and opened first. The public project is months behind and nearly double its early estimate.
There is also a scheduling question. When consultants at Webb Management studied the city theater, they listed Long Bay among the local groups that might use it. With Long Bay Theatre Opened main street, it may not need those outside rental days. That leaves CCU and the city to show who will fill them.
City leaders have pitched the arts district as a long-term bet on the old downtown core. At the 2024 groundbreaking, Bethune called the theater project “human infrastructure” for residents and businesses [BroadwayWorld, 2024]. She has also said the broader plan could draw as much as $1 billion in private investment.
Long Bay is now the first real test of that idea. A full season of shows, each with several weekend performances, gives nearby restaurants and shops predictable busy nights. Some property owners are already counting on that. A recent listing for a storefront at 742 Main Street advertises Long Bay Theater, Mt. Atlanticus mini golf, Sun City Cafe and the CCU theater as neighbors [CommercialCafe, 2026].
The Long Bay Theatre opened question is whether two theaters on one block will help each other or compete for the same ticket buyers. In the best case, a 200-seat community stage and a 300-seat university hall give people more reasons to make downtown a regular night out. In the worst case, they split a local audience that is still getting used to the idea of going to Main Street for entertainment.
Parking, lighting and walkability will matter as much as what is on stage. So will the shows. Long Bay’s lineup leans on comedies and familiar musicals, while CCU will bring student productions. That mix may be different enough to bring in different crowds.
Long Bay’s next show on Main Street is Single Bells, a holiday musical that pokes fun at made-for-TV Christmas movies. It runs Dec. 2–20 [Long Bay Theatre box office, 2026]. Earlier season-ticket packages had listed Elf the Musical for those dates [Long Bay Theatre box office, 2026]. The rest of the season, as listed on the company’s box office site:
| Show | Dates |
|---|---|
| Single Bells | Dec. 2–20, 2026 |
| Dog Mom, a new comedy by Tate Hanyuk (Coastal Voices Initiative) | Jan. 13–17, 2027 |
| Peter Pan Goes Wrong | Feb. 17–28, 2027 |
| Sordid Lives | Mar. 24–Apr. 4, 2027 |
| Oliver! | May 5–16, 2027 |
The company has also promoted its first-ever summer season, opening with Little Shop of Horrors at the new venue [Long Bay Theatre box office, 2026]. A summer slate would put the stage to work during tourist season, when downtown foot traffic should be at its highest.
Across the street, residents should watch for three things: when the CCU theater actually opens, what it finally costs, and whether City Council finds any of the savings it asked staff to look for. Locals who want to support Long Bay can still give to its capital campaign or Center Stage Fund.
For now, the first theater as the Long Bay Theatre Opened in downtown’s new arts district was built by a small nonprofit, paid for by neighbors, and finished just in time for opening night.
Long Bay Theatre Opened – Long Bay Theatre to open new downtown Myrtle Beach venue this week with Mary Poppins — WPDE, Oct. 6, 2026
Long Bay Theatre Opened – Long Bay Theatre’s New Location To Open With Mary Poppins — WFXB, Oct. 6, 2026
Long Bay Theatre Opened – Behind the scenes of Mary Poppins and what’s ahead for Long Bay Theatre — WMBF, Sept. 17, 2026
Long Bay Theatre Opened – Long Bay Theatre box office and season listings and season packages — ThunderTix, 2026
Long Bay Theatre Opened – Taxpayers on hook for $23M for theater. Can Myrtle Beach cut costs to save money? — The Sun News (via AOL), 2026
Downtown Myrtle Beach wants to be a magnet for arts and culture. CCU is buying in. — The Sun News (via Yahoo)
CCU and the city of Myrtle Beach break ground on a new theatre facility — Coastal Carolina University, July 22, 2024
Myrtle Beach takes steps towards bringing performing arts theater to downtown — City of Myrtle Beach, Feb. 29, 2024
Myrtle Beach Will Get New $22.3 Million Theater in Downtown Revitalization Effort — BroadwayWorld, July 23, 2024
Fifth Act: Myrtle Beach’s Long Bay Theatre celebrates its fifth anniversary in 2025 — Sasee, Aug. 1, 2025
Long Bay Theatre Opened – Greg London: Long Bay Theatre — Grand Strand Magazine, August 2025
The Play That Goes Wrong at Long Bay Theatre — BroadwayWorld, 2022
742 Main St listing — CommercialCafe, 2026